Choosing the perfect pacifier can be surprisingly complex, with so many types, shapes, and materials available. Finding one that works for both you and your baby can take a little trial and error, but knowing what features to look for can help streamline the process. Here’s a guide to finding the ideal pacifier, along with some tips to make the experience positive for both of you.
1. Consider the Shape
Pacifiers come in several shapes, and your baby may prefer one over another. The three most common shapes are:
- Orthodontic: Shaped with a rounded top and flat bottom, orthodontic pacifiers support the natural movement of your baby’s tongue and mouth. This shape is designed to help reduce the risk of dental issues.
- Round (or Cherry): Shaped like a rounded ball at the tip, these pacifiers more closely mimic a mother’s nipple and may be comforting for babies transitioning from breastfeeding.
- Butterfly or Contoured: With a butterfly-shaped shield, these pacifiers give extra space around the nose and mouth, which some babies find more comfortable.
Starting with an orthodontic or rounded shape can be a good choice, but be prepared to try different options to see what your baby prefers.
2. Choose the Right Size
Pacifiers are generally sized according to age groups (e.g., 0-6 months, 6-18 months). Using the correct size ensures the pacifier fits comfortably and safely in your baby’s mouth. A pacifier that’s too large may cause gagging, while one that’s too small may not provide enough comfort.
3. Think About Materials
Pacifiers are usually made from latex or silicone. Here are some differences between the two:
- Silicone: Silicone pacifiers are firm, easy to clean, and durable. They’re a good option for babies with latex allergies and are less likely to retain odors.
- Latex: Latex pacifiers are softer and more flexible than silicone, which some babies may prefer. However, they may wear out faster and can retain odors over time.
Silicone is often the most popular choice because of its durability and hypoallergenic properties, but some babies respond better to the softness of latex.
4. Opt for a One-Piece Design
A one-piece pacifier design is typically safer than two-piece pacifiers since it has fewer parts that could come apart. A one-piece pacifier made from a single piece of molded material reduces the risk of choking, especially as your baby grows and becomes more active.
5. Look for a Safe Shield
The shield, or the outer part of the pacifier, should be large enough to prevent the baby from putting the whole pacifier in their mouth. Shields should have ventilation holes to prevent moisture buildup, which can lead to skin irritation around the mouth.
6. Select BPA-Free Materials
Check that any pacifier you choose is made from BPA-free materials, especially if it contains plastic parts. Most baby products are now BPA-free, but it’s always a good idea to double-check.
7. Easy to Clean
Babies drop pacifiers constantly, so choosing one that’s easy to clean can make life simpler. Dishwasher-safe silicone pacifiers or those that come with sterilizing cases are convenient. Many parents find that one-piece designs are easier to clean thoroughly, as there are fewer crevices for bacteria to hide.
8. Consider Self-Soothing Features
Some pacifiers come with self-soothing features, like attached loveys (small, soft blankets or animals). These can help babies learn to soothe themselves and make it easier for you to locate the pacifier when it gets dropped.
9. Introduce Slowly and Monitor Usage
Once you choose a pacifier, introduce it slowly and see how your baby responds. Some babies will take to a pacifier right away, while others may need time to get used to it. Observe how your baby reacts and be willing to try different options if needed. And remember, it’s best to introduce pacifiers after breastfeeding routines are well established to avoid potential nipple confusion.
The Role of Moogco Silver Nursing Cups
If you're breastfeeding, your comfort matters too. Moogco Silver Nursing Cups provide a natural, gentle relief for sore nipples, helping you stay comfortable as you and your baby adjust to new routines. Using natural antibacterial silver, Moogco Nursing Cups promote healing without the need for chemicals, making them a soothing, eco-friendly option for nursing moms. With products like these, you can enjoy a more comfortable breastfeeding journey while also finding the right tools, like pacifiers, to support your baby’s self-soothing needs.
Final Thoughts
Choosing a pacifier is all about finding what works best for your baby and fits seamlessly into your life. By focusing on safety, comfort, and your baby’s preferences, you can feel confident in your choice. And remember, pacifiers are just one tool in your parenting toolkit—flexibility and patience will help you find the right balance for you and your baby.
Bring this guide home with 25% off.
Use code READER25 for 25% off →
Frequently Asked Questions
When is the best time to introduce a pacifier to my newborn?
Most experts recommend waiting until breastfeeding is well established, usually around 3 to 4 weeks, before introducing a pacifier. This helps prevent nipple confusion and ensures your milk supply is regulated. If you're exclusively formula feeding, you can introduce a pacifier earlier if you choose.
How often should I replace my baby's pacifier?
You should inspect pacifiers regularly for signs of wear like cracks, tears, or stickiness, and replace them every 2 to 4 weeks or sooner if damaged. Silicone pacifiers tend to last longer than latex ones. Always discard a pacifier immediately if you notice any deterioration, as it can become a choking hazard.
Pediatric-dentist approved styles
Soothing picks for fussy moments
Take 25% off at checkout, applied automatically when you shop through this link.
Shop with READER25 →Free US shipping over $100. Code applies automatically at checkout.
Can using a pacifier affect my baby's teeth?
Pacifier use is generally safe for dental development in the first two years. However, prolonged use beyond age 2 or 3 can potentially affect tooth alignment and jaw development. Orthodontic-shaped pacifiers are designed to minimize dental impact, and most pediatric dentists recommend weaning from pacifiers by age 2.
What should I do if my baby refuses every pacifier I try?
Some babies simply don't take to pacifiers, and that's perfectly okay. Try offering it at different times, like after feeding when your baby is calm but not too sleepy. You can also try different shapes and materials, but if your baby continues to refuse, don't force it. Many babies find other ways to self-soothe, like sucking on their fingers or cuddling.
Is it safe to use pacifier clips or attachments?
Pacifier clips can be safe and convenient when used properly. Choose clips that are specifically designed for pacifiers, no longer than 6 to 8 inches, and attach them to your baby's clothing, never around their neck. Always supervise your baby while using clips and remove them during sleep to prevent any strangulation risk.
How do I properly sterilize a new pacifier before first use?
Before first use, sterilize new pacifiers by boiling them in water for 5 minutes or using a steam sterilizer. After the initial sterilization, you can clean pacifiers with hot soapy water or run them through the dishwasher. For daily cleaning, warm soapy water is usually sufficient, and avoid putting pacifiers in your own mouth to clean them, as this can transfer bacteria.
Can I give my baby a pacifier if I'm exclusively breastfeeding?
Yes, you can offer a pacifier while exclusively breastfeeding, but it's best to wait until nursing is well established, typically 3 to 4 weeks postpartum. This allows your baby to master the breastfeeding latch and helps ensure your milk supply is robust. Once breastfeeding is going smoothly, a pacifier can be a helpful tool for sleep and soothing without interfering with nursing.
What's the difference between nighttime and daytime pacifiers?
Nighttime pacifiers often glow in the dark or have features that make them easier to find and reinsert during sleep. Some also have a more contoured shield for comfort when lying down. Daytime pacifiers may have brighter colors or attached toys for stimulation. Functionally, both types work the same way, so the choice comes down to convenience and your baby's preferences.
From Moogco Studio
Printable and personalized nursery essentials. Designed by moms for moms.
About the Editor
Eda Ulger is the editor at Moogco Baby and a mom of two. She curates and edits our guides so every piece is honest, practical, and genuinely helpful for the early days of motherhood.
