Clothing
Nursing & Feeding
Health & Care
Diaper & Potty
Toys
Travel
Home
For Moms

Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

What to look for: For a breastfed baby, a one-piece silicone or natural-rubber pacifier with a thin, flexible nipple lets the tongue stay in a natural latch position. Wait until breastfeeding is well established, usually around 3 to 4 weeks, before introducing one.

  • One-piece designs have nothing to detach and are easiest to sterilise
  • Match the size to your baby's age, an outgrown shield presses the gums
  • Natural rubber has a rounder, breast-like feel, silicone is firmer and lasts longer
  • Replace every 4 to 6 weeks or at the first sign of tearing

These are the in-stock pacifiers our team reaches for with breastfed babies. For the full breakdown of shapes, materials and timing, read our guide to the best pacifiers for breastfed babies.

13 products
13 products
Sort by:
  • Featured
  • Most relevant
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
Active Flexy Pacifier for babies 4 months and up, featuring a flexible design for comfort and soothing. Active Flexy Pacifier for babies 4 months and up, featuring a flexible design for comfort and soothing.

Nanobébé

Nanobébé Active Flexy Pacifier 4m+ 4-pack Pink Teal Black Sky

$14.99
$14.99
Mushie FRIGG Daisy Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack Daisy Shield Mushie FRIGG Daisy Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack Daisy Shield

Mushie

Mushie FRIGG Daisy Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack Daisy Shield

$14.99
$14.99
★★★★★ ★★★★★ 5.0 (39)
Mushie FRIGG Moon Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack Soft Colors Mushie FRIGG Moon Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack Soft Colors

Mushie

Mushie FRIGG Moon Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack Soft Colors

$14.99
$14.99
★★★★★ ★★★★★ 4.9 (15)
Onyx silicone pacifier for babies, soft, safe, and stylish design for comfort and soothing.

littleCHEW

littleCHEW Silicone Pacifier Onyx 0-12 months

$11.00
$11.00

Good to know

Over $100? Shipping is on us.

Free US shipping, no code needed. It just happens at checkout.

Soft Sage Silicone Pacifier - Safe, gentle, and stylish for your baby's comfort.

littleCHEW

littleCHEW Silicone Pacifier Soft Sage 0-12 months

$11.00
$11.00
Sage silicone pacifier for babies, soft and safe for soothing comfort.

littleCHEW

littleCHEW Silicone Pacifier Sage 0-12 months

$11.00
$11.00
Mushie FRIGG Daisy Silicone Pacifier 2-Pack Mushie FRIGG Daisy Silicone Pacifier 2-Pack

Mushie

Mushie FRIGG Daisy Silicone Pacifier 2-Pack

$14.99
$14.99
★★★★★ ★★★★★ 4.5 (221)
FRIGG Butterfly Anatomical Silicone Pacifier 2-Pack for infants 0-6 months, featuring a cute butterfly design. FRIGG Butterfly Anatomical Silicone Pacifier 2-Pack for infants 0-6 months, featuring a cute butterfly design.

Mushie

Mushie FRIGG Butterfly Anatomical Silicone Pacifier 2-Pack 0-6 Months

$16.99
$16.99
★★★★★ ★★★★★ 4.9 (25)
FRIGG Lucky Symmetrical Silicone Pacifier 2-Pack for babies 0-6 months, featuring soft, safe, and stylish designs. FRIGG Lucky Symmetrical Silicone Pacifier 2-Pack for babies 0-6 months, featuring soft, safe, and stylish designs.

Mushie

Mushie FRIGG Lucky Symmetrical Silicone Pacifier 0-6 Months 2-Pack

$16.99
$16.99
★★★★★ ★★★★★ 4.6 (305)
FRIGG Little Viking Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack in soft colors, perfect for soothing babies. FRIGG Little Viking Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack in soft colors, perfect for soothing babies.

Mushie

Mushie FRIGG Little Viking Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack

$14.99
$14.99
★★★★★ ★★★★★ 4.7 (69)
Mushie FRIGG Andersen Fairytale Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack Mushie FRIGG Andersen Fairytale Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack

Mushie

Mushie FRIGG Andersen Fairytale Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack

$14.99
$14.99
★★★★★ ★★★★★ 4.7 (286)

Take your time

Split it into 4, interest-free.

Choose Shop Pay at checkout to split any order between $50 and $1,000 into four payments. No interest, no fees.

Mushie FRIGG Rope Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack soft colors Mushie FRIGG Rope Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack soft colors

Mushie

Mushie FRIGG Rope Natural Rubber Pacifier 2-Pack soft colors

$14.99
$14.99
★★★★★ ★★★★★ 4.6 (712)
FRIGG Natural Rubber Pacifier 4-Pack in assorted colors for babies, promoting comfort and soothing. FRIGG Natural Rubber Pacifier 4-Pack in assorted colors for babies, promoting comfort and soothing.

Mushie

Mushie FRIGG Natural Rubber Pacifier 4-Pack Curated Palette

$24.99
$24.99
★★★★★ ★★★★★ 4.9 (15)

Parent-Loved Favorites

Swaddelini Grey Swaddle Sleep Sack 3D Knit Seamless Wearable Swaddelini Grey Swaddle Sleep Sack 3D Knit Seamless Wearable
BESTSELLER

Swaddelini

Swaddelini Grey Swaddle Sleep Sack 3D Knit Seamless Wearable

$54.95
$54.95
Lavender Swaddle Sleep Sack for babies, soft and cozy, perfect for peaceful sleep and comfort. Lavender Swaddle Sleep Sack for babies, soft and cozy, perfect for peaceful sleep and comfort.
BESTSELLER

Swaddelini

Swaddelini Lavender Swaddle Sleep Sack 3D knit lightweight

$54.95
$54.95
Swaddelini Pink Swaddle Sleep Sack 3D Knit Seamless Swaddelini Pink Swaddle Sleep Sack 3D Knit Seamless

Swaddelini

Swaddelini Pink Swaddle Sleep Sack 3D Knit Seamless

$54.95
$54.95
★ Moogco Pick
"Morning Sickness Box - thoughtful baby gift set for expecting mothers, featuring essential comfort items." "Morning Sickness Box - thoughtful baby gift set for expecting mothers, featuring essential comfort items."

Sunflower Motherhood

Sunflower Motherhood Morning Sickness Box nausea relief gift set

$65.00
$65.00
Organic cotton futon pad in rectangle shape, customizable size, perfect for babies' comfort and safety. Organic cotton futon pad in rectangle shape, customizable size, perfect for babies' comfort and safety.
BESTSELLER
LOW STOCK

Wendy Anne

Wendy Anne Organic Cotton Futon Pad Rectangle Custom Size

From $69.00
From $69.00
Little Martin's Portable Fetal Doppler - Hear Your Baby's Heartbeat Anytime - Rechargeable Batteries by USB - FDA Cleared - MOOGCO Baby Little Martin's Portable Fetal Doppler - Hear Your Baby's Heartbeat Anytime - Rechargeable Batteries by USB - FDA Cleared - MOOGCO Baby

Little Martin's Drawer

Little Martin's Portable Fetal Doppler USB Rechargeable LCD

$69.99
$69.99
Save 75%
Lil Learnerz Training Pants 2pk by tokidoki x Kanga Care in tokiCorno design for fun potty training. Lil Learnerz Training Pants 2pk by tokidoki x Kanga Care in tokiCorno design for fun potty training.

Kanga Care

Kanga Care Lil Learnerz Training Pants tokiCorno 2pk

$7.00
$7.00 -74%
$27.99
Save 75%
Lil Learnerz Training Pants 2pk - tokidoki x Kanga Care - tokiSweet for easy potty training. Lil Learnerz Training Pants 2pk - tokidoki x Kanga Care - tokiSweet for easy potty training.

Kanga Care

Kanga Care Lil Learnerz Training Pants 2pk tokiSweet tokidoki

$7.00
$7.00 -74%
$27.99
★★★★★ ★★★★★ 4.7 (1282)
momjug breastfeeding water bottle 50oz double-wall stainless steel momjug breastfeeding water bottle 50oz double-wall stainless steel

momjug

momjug breastfeeding water bottle 50oz double-wall stainless steel

From $49.99
From $49.99
Smocked Blue First Birthday Bubble - MOOGCO Baby Smocked Blue First Birthday Bubble - MOOGCO Baby

Seven Lantern Lane

Seven Lantern Lane Smocked Blue Birthday Bubble Baby Boy 12M-2T

$49.99
$49.99
Lounger Nest Organic Cotton Futon - MOOGCO Baby Lounger Nest Organic Cotton Futon - MOOGCO Baby

Wendy Anne

Wendy Anne Lounger Nest Organic Cotton Futon Oval Bolstered

From $129.00
From $129.00
Create A Castle Basic Tower Kit 10 inch Split Molds Sand Snow Create A Castle Basic Tower Kit 10 inch Split Molds Sand Snow

Create A Castle

Create A Castle Basic Tower Kit 10 inch Split Molds Sand Snow

$39.98
$39.98
Save 19%
Avenlur.com Spruce Foldable Baby Swing Indoor 6-36 months Pine Wood Avenlur.com Spruce Foldable Baby Swing Indoor 6-36 months Pine Wood

Avenlur.com

Avenlur.com Spruce Foldable Baby Swing Indoor 6-36 months Pine Wood

$129.00
$129.00 -18%
$159.00
★★★★★ ★★★★★ 4.9 (429)
LELLOBABY™ X Hampton BABY Deluxe Rattan Diaper Caddy for stylish and organized baby care. LELLOBABY™ X Hampton BABY Deluxe Rattan Diaper Caddy for stylish and organized baby care.

LELLOBABY

LELLOBABY Deluxe Rattan Diaper Caddy Handmade 14.25x10.25x6.5

$99.00
$99.00